Washington Sundar’s strong batting display in the opening Test at Eden Gardens has sparked a fresh debate within India’s team management: should he continue as a specialist No. 3, and if so, what does that mean for his role as a bowler?
The spotlight on India’s batting order grew sharper this week after coaches experimented with Sai Sudharsan’s technique during practice. Head coach Gautam Gambhir had the young left-hander bat without a back pad while facing spin at the nets — a drill aimed at preventing him from getting stuck on the back foot, something that can be costly against quality spinners like Keshav Maharaj and Simon Harmer. The move suggested that Sai is being seriously considered for the playing XI in the upcoming second Test in Guwahati.
But the moment Sai returns to the No. 3 slot, the immediate concern becomes Washington Sundar’s position.
Sundar’s Impressive Test at Eden Gardens
On a turning surface in the first Test, Sundar showed admirable composure against spin. He lasted long spells at the crease — 82 and 92 balls — and made 29 and 31 in challenging conditions. His willingness to move forward decisively and meet the ball early stood out on a pitch where most top-order batters struggled.
Gambhir openly praised his approach after the match, noting that Sundar handled the South African spinners with confidence and maturity.
Experts Weigh In
Former India opener and coach WV Raman, who has tracked Sundar’s development closely, believes the allrounder still has areas to refine. While Sundar often takes a long stride to counter spin, Raman feels that a slightly shorter step might allow him to judge the ball better. Even so, Raman considers Sundar’s technique against spin to be one of the most secure among India’s current top-order options.
Raman, however, is clear about one thing: Sundar should be given a stable position high in the batting order. Constantly moving him down, he says, could restrict his development.
The No. 3 Conundrum
India’s search for a permanent No. 3 has been ongoing ever since Shubman Gill shifted to No. 4 following Virat Kohli’s retirement. Sai Sudharsan was initially chosen for the role, but brief changes during the England series — where Karun Nair filled in — added to the uncertainty.
Sai has shown improvement in his front-foot play and produced good scores against the West Indies earlier this year, making the final call between him and Sundar a tough one for the management.
What About Sundar’s Bowling?
Another major concern is whether pushing Sundar higher up the order will diminish his contribution as an off-spinner. He bowled only one over in Kolkata, raising questions about how India plans to balance his dual skill set.
Raman insists Sundar is far more than a part-time bowler and should not be underutilized. According to him, Sundar should be groomed as a top-order batter who can also deliver meaningful overs — not the other way around.
